It is clear that walter kirn is an excellent writer. The undereducation of an overachiever, the witty, selfcastigating story of the authors. Like 1984 and brave new world, the rise of the meritocracy, written in 1958, provides one of the great dystopian visions of the twentieth century. I love walter kirns memoir lost in the meritocracy discussing his time at princeton. Yeah, even many books are offered, this book can steal the reader heart suitably much. Lost in the meritocracy by walter kirn overdrive rakuten. He clapped erasers, memorized answer keys, and parroted his teachers pet. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Lee lost in the meritocracy the undereducation of an overachiever por walter kirn disponible en rakuten kobo. The short story is more a reflection of the author about his youth that profoundly takes the reader to all the events of his youth. A new york times notable book a daily beast best book of the yeara huffington post best book of the year from elementary school on, walter kirn knew how to stay at the top of his class. In this whipsmart memoir of kissingup, cramming, and competition, lost in the meritocracy reckons the costs of an educational system where the point is simply to keep accumulating points and never to. The undereducation of an overachiever by walter kirn doubleday, i expected a semidry expose on the problems facing the american education system with an emphasis on the ivy league schools.
Read lost in the meritocracy the undereducation of an overachiever by walter kirn available from rakuten kobo. Kirn aims to burst the pretensions of the american ideal of meritocracyastutely analyzed in nicholas lemanns the big test. It describes his own trip through the american education system from rural minnesota to princeton university. In this whipsmart memoir of kissingup, cramming, and competition, lost in the meritocracy reckons the costs of an educational system where the point is simply to keep accumulating points and never to look backor within. When i heard the title, lost in the meritocracy, i immediately searched for it online. But when he launched himself eastward to an ivy league university, kirn discovered that the temple of higher learning he had.
A fine narrative of what it is to be young, lost, deeply immersed in drugs, and frequently on the verge of a nervous breakdown. Walter kirn, author of lost in the meritocracy, on his college breakdown, colliding with clubby rich kids, and the book that brought all the horror rushing back. One of the first chapters describes kirns experience with uncle admiral, a sort of mentor when he was very young. Someone whose taste in and judgment of literature i respect added it and after glancing at the synopsis i did, also. He checked off all of the appropriate boxes, followed the rules, and never took a step back to consider why he was mindlessly moving from one milestone to the next. Lost in the meritocracy reckons up the costs of a system where the point is simply to keep accumulating points and never to look backor within. Or are they primarily fueled by money, prestige, old boy networks, superficiality, and any other number of distasteful. Lost in the meritocracy a new york times notable book a daily beast best book of the yeara huffington post best book of the year from elementary school on, walter kirn knew how to stay at the top of his class. In placing blame for their ignorance, though, lost in the meritocracy is hazier. And young walter, it should be said,does know something. A new york times notable book a daily beast best book of the year a huffington post best book of the year from elementary. What makes the book peculiar, however, is that modern politicians have unashamedly taken the values of meritocracy including the word itself and have claimed them as the central and most desirable feature of a modern society. Bookslut kirn shows, better than any recent book, how our educational system is perverted from beginning to end.
And that, in the end, is a fundamental question surrounding these schools, one that kirns book lost in the meritocracy promises to answer. Like many memoirs, lost in the meritocracy combines penetrating shrewdness with remarkable blind spots. Although ive never read an article or book by the author previously, i know why lost in the meritocracy is in my tbr list. The undereducation of an overachiever is a 2009 memoir by walter. The witty, selfcastigating story of how walter kirns schooling left him not so much educated as wised up. The most burnished meritocrats may, in fact, know nothing. How did anyone as smart as kirn get into such a fix. The content and theme of this book truly will lie alongside your heart. It describes his own trip through the american education system from rural minnesota to princeton university the author also wrote an earlier essay under the same title for the atlantic. The undereducation of an overachiever by walter kirn and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at. Walter kirn chronicles the authors trip through american higher education, where standardized tests, class rankings and gamesmanship stand in the way of true intellectual fulfillment, revealing the psychic. Mar 14, 2019 for the throgmortons of the world who encountered meritocracy in the seemingly hopeful title of youngs book without investigating further, the word might have seemed to represent an.
Meritocracy is a book for all those of the postwar generation who have mourned the loss of their true best and brightest, and who regret how the life of their nation, so brightly and hopefully imagined by themselves when they were young, and now entrusted to their care, has come to be diminished. Lost in the meritocracy ebook by walter kirn rakuten kobo. A new york times notable book a daily beast best book of the year a huffington post best book of the year from elementar. A new york times notable book a daily beast best book of the yeara huffington post best book of the year from elementary school on, walter kirn knew how to stay at. He has an implicit knowledge of what it is that people in authority educators, mainly want from him and. For the throgmortons of the world who encountered meritocracy in the seemingly hopeful title of youngs book without investigating further, the word might have seemed to represent an. What gives lost in the meritocracy a sharper edge is the wrinkle in time that might be called the age of theory, and that just happened to coincide with mr kirns school days. May 19, 2009 lost in the meritocracy reckons up the costs of a system where the point is simply to keep accumulating points and never to look backor within. Jul 26, 2009 somewhere in the ivyclad halls of princeton, admissions officers must be wringing their hands over lost in the meritocracy.
The undereducation of an overachiever by walter kirn. A new york times notable book a daily beast best book of the year a huffington post best book of the year from elementary school on, walter kirn knew how. There is some fresh material in the book that is well worth it. A new york times notable book a daily beast best book of the year a huffington post best book of the year from elementary school on. In my private princeton honors program, the deployment of key words was crucial, just as the recognition of them ahd been on the sat. Thats the species of catastrophe recounted in walter kirns memoir, lost in the meritocracy. The short reading that has been considered for the purpose of this response paper is lost in the meritocracy written by walter kirn. He clapped erasers, memorized answer keys, and parroted his teachers pet theories. Lost in the meritocracy ebook por walter kirn 9780385529266. Jun 23, 2009 lost in the meritocracy, which on one level is also an indictment of how easily our educational bureaucracy can be traduced by ingratiating bullshit, pivots on kirns assessment of his shrewdness his very braininess as a toxic gift that turned him into the undereducated overachiever of the book s subtitle. Expanding or bloating it into some sort of forced bildungsromanslashromp dilutes the knowledge gained from his experiences, at quite a high cost.
The author also wrote an earlier essay under the same title for the atlantic. A new york times notable book a daily beast best book of the year a huffington post best book of the year from elementary school on, walter kirn knew how to stay at the top of his class. Apr 07, 2017 i love walter kirns memoir lost in the meritocracy discussing his time at princeton. He checked off all of the appropriate boxes, followed the rules, and never took a step back to consider why he was.
Lost in the meritocracy by walter kirn, 9780307279453, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. Jun 22, 2010 lost in the meritocracy by walter kirn, 9780307279453, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. Lost in the meritocracyreckons up the costs of a system where the point is simply to keep accumulating points and never to look backor within. Lost in the meritocracy was so much better as an essay, rich with humor and insight, revealing a world that i fear is still not widely known. Walter kirn a new york times notable book a daily beast best book of the year a huffington post best book of the year from elementary school on, walter kirn knew how to stay at the top of his class. Stories, she needed me, thumbsucker, up in the air, mission to america and the unbinding. Lost in the meritocracy reckons up the costs of a system where the point is simply to keep accumulating points and never to look backaor within. For such a culturally connected social critic, these are curious oversights. But i strongly advise you to read the original essay lost in the meritocracy first. The meritocracy trap is an exhausting book bombastic, repetitive, and singleminded to the point of obsession, a mixture of cotton mather, karl marx, and maga. The rise of the meritocracy is a book by british sociologist and politician michael dunlop young which was first published in 1958. The undereducation of an overachiever is a 2009 memoir by walter kirn. It describes a dystopian society in a future united kingdom in which intelligence and merit have become the central tenet of society, replacing previous divisions of social class and creating a society stratified between a merited powerholding elite and a. May 24, 2009 thats the species of catastrophe recounted in walter kirns memoir, lost in the meritocracy.
She dated one of the guys a few months back, but lately shes grown serious, ambitious. He briefly mentioned this book, which he was writing at the time, expanding an essay he wrote in the atlantic about his life at princeton. He clapped erasers, memorized answer keys, and parroted his teachers. The book takes the form of a confession, as kirn deploys his experiences to. Somewhere in the ivyclad halls of princeton, admissions officers must be wringing their hands over lost in the meritocracy. Paul to take the test that will help determine who will get ahead in life, who will stay put, and who will fall behind, two of my closest buddies seal their fates by opening pint bottles of cherry schnapps the moment we leave the high school parking lot. Its a remarkable book that suggests the first step toward intellectual fulfillment is getting off the treadmill that is the american meritocracy. Illsuited for a booklength work, kirns premise found more effective expression as a feature in the atlantic. Lost in the meritocracy air force digital media program. Had lost in the meritocracy loosened the knot that is looped and relooped around the neck of its subject and widened its aperture it might have encircled larger themes, and been a better book. She dated one of the guys a few months back, but lately shes grown. Lost in the meritocracy undereducation of an overachiever. The undereducation of an overachiever kirn, walter on. Illsuited for a book length work, kirns premise found more effective expression as a feature in the atlantic.
A prominent writercritic recounts how he barely survived the careless kindnesses of college. The undereducation of an overachiever by kirn, walter isbn. One comes early in its pages, when kirn recalls how as a teenager he read the great gatsby and, like its author and its narrator, yearned to leave minnesota and head east. The novelist walter kirns new memoir, lost in the meritocracy, contains several references to f. Indeed, by the end of the book i found myself wondering whether education reform was xs real subject at all. Growing up in rural minnesota, he fixated on attending an elite university.
314 1686 1289 925 668 839 5 1324 59 1469 1293 1558 400 178 1077 499 1137 1004 2 378 12 1295 77 1359 992 1143 1063 479 760 61 1067 173 726 109